CG's Lash Exact or Maybelline's Full 'n' Soft? (waterproof)?

I've been haunting www.makeupalley.com for awhile now trying to decide on a good mascara, and these two keep on coming up. Which do you girls think is the better one?CG's Lash Exact or Maybelline's Full 'n' Soft? (waterproof)?
i actually like volume exact by covergirl better than lash exact. it plumps without clumping. i didn't like any of the maybelline mascaras at all. i use the regular formula, it works fine, unless you plan to cry a lot, or go swimming. the waterproof is very hard to take off.CG's Lash Exact or Maybelline's Full 'n' Soft? (waterproof)?
I dont really like CoverGirl or Maybelline but if I had to choose probably Full N Soft
I'm on Make-up Alley, too, but I personally am not a fan of either. My HG (you know what that means, right?) is Rimmel Extra Super Lash Mascara. It's between two to three dollars, so you can't go wrong!
i have both mascara but i like maybelline's better, but i was use different mascaras on different ocastions
Have tried Maybeline Full %26amp; Soft before , its OK if you want full lashes, and you have lashes to begin with. For people with sparse lashes , Loreal Lash Architect / Le Grand Curl is better. (It gives a fan like effect). Waterproof is not good in the long run , it makes your lashes fall off. Alternate with non waterproof mascara.
umm lets try mac eylash primer and then the mac pro long eyelash mascara trust me they are worht buying
CG's Lash Exact, FER SURE.


lol.


i hate waterproof stuff


i can never get it off


then i have to sleep with it on


and it gets on my pillows.


lol.
Personally I avoid any mascara that is waterproof. It is hard to take off and usually makes eyelashes fall off. If I chose from those I'd go for the CG Lash Exact but just not waterproof. I find that Full 'N' Soft chunks up a lot